How Used Car Scams Snare Both Sellers and Lenders

How Used Car Scams Snare Both Sellers and Lenders

By Greg Collier

Fraudsters are exploiting vehicle sales and auto financing in creative ways, and both ends of the market (buyers and lenders) are at risk.

The Car Looks Fine, Until It’s Not:

You list your car for sale. A buyer comes and takes it for what seems like a normal test drive. Later you learn they deliberately poured oil into the engine, staged a mechanical problem, and coerced you to sell the car at a deep discount. Or you apply for an auto loan, everything looks legitimate, but the identity is fake, the income inflated, and the vehicle ends up abandoned or resold overseas, leaving you (or your lender) on the hook.

In the Bay Area, two men were recently arrested after attempting the “oil-in-the-engine” scam. They tried to purchase a car at a steep discount by faking mechanical problems during a test drive.

Meanwhile, U.S. lenders reported that auto lending fraud hit roughly $9.2 billion in 2024, including schemes such as synthetic identities, credit washing, and fake dealership websites.

What’s Going On:

There are two major car-fraud vectors right now:

1. Seller-Targeted Scheme (“Oil-in-the-Engine” Type):

  • A fraudster sees your for-sale listing.
  • They ask for a test drive and during that drive deliberately cause or simulate a mechanical issue (e.g., pour oil in the engine, fake damage).
  • They then use the “issue” as leverage to force you to accept a much lower sale price.
  • After purchase, the fraudster may swap plates, resell the vehicle, or abandon it, leaving you with a big loss or legal mess.

2. Buyer/Finance-Targeted Scheme (Auto Loan Fraud):

  • Fraudsters submit loan applications using false or synthetic identities, inflated income, or credit-washing tactics.
  • They buy vehicles (often luxury or high-end cars) and then vanish—no repayment; the vehicle might be shipped overseas or re-titled.

Lenders bear large losses because the borrower credentials looked legitimate and the vehicle collateral might be compromised or unrecoverable.

Why It’s Effective:

  • Private-party car sales often have minimal safeguards—less paperwork, fewer checks, so scammer flexibility is high.
  • Digital-first auto loan processes (online applications, remote verification) make it easier for fraudsters to use fake or synthetic identities.
  • The dual pressures of consumer demand for fast purchases and lenders for streamlined approvals reduce scrutiny.
  • Vehicles have value and mobility—they can be moved, retitled, and exported, making recovery difficult.
  • Trust and urgency fuel the scams—sellers rush to close a deal, buyers rush to secure financing, and both end up letting their guard down.

Red Flags:

For Sellers:

  • A buyer insists on a test drive without proper verification of their license or payment method.
  • During the test drive something “odd” happens—the seller doesn’t understand the issue but feels pressured to deal.
  • The buyer tries to negotiate a large discount, citing mechanical trouble found during the test drive.
  • The payment method is unusual, or they ask for an unconventional arrangement (money down + later, etc.).

For Buyers / Lenders:

  • Credit application uses little or no verifiable history or references a shell employer.
  • The dealership or seller appears rushed or says, “We’ll do paperwork later” but already hands over the vehicle.
  • Vehicle being financed is high-end, out of keeping with buyer’s apparent profile.
  • Lender notices loan applicant’s information mismatches (address, SSN, employment).
  • Post-purchase, the vehicle disappears or is shipped/exported, with no contact from the buyer.

Quick Tip: For a private car sale, always verify buyer identity, use escrow or secure payment, get a vehicle history report, and draft a clear bill of sale. For lenders, include strong identity validation, verify income/employment, and monitor vehicle location after sale.

What You Can Do:

  • As a seller: Require valid ID before test drives, escort during test drives, use secure payment methods, and clear title transfer at sale time.
  • As a buyer: Verify the seller’s identity and title authenticity, inspect the vehicle professionally, and don’t rush into deals that seem “too good.”
  • As a lender: Use fraud detection tools that check for synthetic identities, track vehicle location and registration status, and cross-check employment/income claims.
  • For all parties: Use secure financing platforms, keep documentation of sale/loan, maintain records of test drive interactions and payment communications.
  • Report suspicious transactions to police, to consumer-fraud agencies, and, as needed, to auto-fraud databases.

If You’ve Been Targeted:

  • Contact law enforcement and file a report. Include all documentation (IDs, communications, test drive details, loan documents).
  • Notify your bank or financing company if payments are being mishandled or the vehicle is being misused.
  • For lost vehicle or loan default risk, contact your lender or insurance broker.
  • Place identity fraud alerts if you suspect synthetic identity was used.
  • Share your story in local seller/buyer forums so others can avoid the same trap.

 Final Thoughts:

Car fraud schemes are evolving rapidly. What may appear as a routine sale, test drive, or financing transaction can hide sophisticated deception. Whether you’re buying, selling, or financing a vehicle, a little suspicion and verification go a long way.

If something feels off—a buyer rushes, a vehicle behaves strangely, or a lender’s application looks too neat—take a step back. Protecting your car deal today could save you from thousands in losses tomorrow.

Further Reading:

Discover more from Greg's Corner

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.